AgDaily.com reports:
Deere & Co. faced a setback in its legal battle against AGCO Corp. and Precision Planting LLC as the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit upheld a jury verdict that AGCO did not infringe on Deere’s patents related to high-speed agricultural planting technology. The patents in question, U.S. Patent Nos. 8,813,663 and 9,699,955, cover advanced systems for planting seeds efficiently.
The legal dispute originated when Deere alleged that AGCO’s SpeedTube and vSet2 products infringed on its patents. Deere claimed these systems utilized similar methods of capturing and delivering seeds during planting.
However, the jury found otherwise on Jan. 24, with the district court rejecting Deere’s post-trial motions for a judgment as a matter of law or a new trial on the infringement issue. Deere appealed the decision, but the Federal Circuit affirmed the lower court’s ruling.
The technology at the heart of the dispute focuses on seed meters and delivery systems designed to enhance the precision and speed of planting. Deere’s patents describe mechanisms for capturing seeds and delivering them to a discharge position through an endless member system, ensuring accurate placement.
AGCO countered that its SpeedTube and vSet2 products operate differently, removing seeds by projecting and accelerating them rather than capturing them, as required by Deere’s patents. During the trial, AGCO presented expert testimony and video evidence demonstrating that its products used projection, not capturing, to deliver seeds. This distinction played a critical role in the jury’s verdict and the court’s subsequent rulings.
To read the entire article click here.
